Laws don’t pay my bills! – unnamed Glasgow street worker
Laura Lee on the appalling blindness of “authorities”:
…The last victim of Jack the Ripper, [Mary] Kelly’s body was so badly mutilated that she could only be identified by her hair and eyebrows…Fast forward 127 years and we have surely progressed a great deal since then in terms of sex worker safety, right? Well no, actually. If anything it’s worse. Following the removal of the tolerance zone for street prostitution in Edinburgh, crimes against sex workers shot up by 95%. The reason for that is simple, it became known that the police were no longer there to protect the workers, but rather to harass and arrest them, and their clients. Let’s make a clear distinction for once and all, many attackers of sex workers are not or will never be “sex buyers”. They are predators, looking for an easy target, and they know that sex workers are alone, vulnerable and highly unlikely to report an attack to the police…152 sex workers have been murdered since 1990. How many more Mary Kellys must we have before the penny drops that leaving vulnerable people open to attack is not a good policy?
If the Church were sanely-run, this article would be true:
The newest leaked information associated with the Vatileaks scandal states that properties owned by the Vatican along Piazza Barberini and the Italian parliament have now been converted to “massage parlours” and saunas, and their patrons are priests. The leaked document points to the Congregation for the Propagation of the Faith…[which] owns and operates numerous properties within Rome. The properties in question are referred to as “peppercorn rents” and are said to be leased for cheap to “powerful colleagues” of the religious institution…
They worked for themselves, but it’s a “ring” and the cops are looking for “pimps”:
Four women have been arrested as part of an alleged prostitution ring operating in Mississippi…Arrested were Anjeni’ Qyanik Moore, 34, of Norfolk, Virginia; Heaven Leigh Nix, 23, of Memphis, Tennessee; Joneka Santrice Burns, 24, of Jackson, Mississippi; and Candace Renee Stewart, 30, of Byhalia, Mississippi…MBI spokesman Warren Strain said the women were working independently and are not believed to be victims of human trafficking. He declined to say…whether they worked with pimps, citing an ongoing investigation…
Lock ’em all up, New York! Let’s put the entire next generation on the “sex offender” registry!
…17 states have changed their child pornography laws so that teenagers who swap nude photos of themselves with each other are not automatically treated as felons. One of those states is New York, which makes an exception for images exchanged between people 20 or younger whose ages are no more than five years apart. In such cases, the “offenders” can avoid criminal charges by undergoing an eight-hour “education reform program” that covers the dangers of sexting and cyberbullying. Despite that provision, two Long Island teenagers were recently charged with felonies for producing and disseminating a 10-second video showing one of them having sex with a girl…the two boys…are both 14…the boys…were each charged with…disseminating indecent material to minors and promoting a sexual performance by a child…In addition to the two boys who were arrested, 20 students were suspended for receiving the video on their cellphones…
The cops are happy to serve as an ex’s revenge goons:
A 50-year-old woman…has been sentenced for soliciting prostitution…Marisa Frances Lang pleaded guilty to prostitution in a public place…and to disorderly conduct…Judge Michael A. Fahey…placed Lang on two years of probation. She was ordered to continue mental health treatment and counseling…and must pay $585 in fines and fees…her ex-husband’s [ratting her out to cops]…led to a sting operation…
…Around the country, pimps…force thousands of…women and girls…into prostitution every day. Florida has the third highest number of sex trafficking cases…Reformers have argued that prostitutes are victims, not criminals, and more effort should be made to go after human traffickers – the pimps…Despite this new focus, a statewide analysis…found that efforts…to investigate and prosecute sex traffickers have yielded few results…[“rescue” profiteers pretend] the image of the independent prostitute, working for herself and selling sex by choice, is rarely accurate…“I [fantasize] the majority who are in the life have been the victims of trafficking,” said Katariina Rosenblatt, founder of There Is HOPE for Me…
The “Facebook pimps” myth is one of the silliest of the whole panic:
…Traffickers worldwide are increasingly using social media to contact vulnerable teenagers and sell them into sex work…Once limited to luring victims in the street, traffickers can now message thousands of people through Instagram, Facebook, Kik, Tagged and Twitter, with WhatsApp and Snapchat some of the latest tools in their arsenal. “If just one of them answers … traffickers can make thousands of dollars off that girl very quickly,” said Andrea Powell, founder and director of FAIR Girls…a growing trend in the United States is to use WhatsApp or Snapchat where messages evaporate over time…Europol…said social media and other online technology have not only taken the recruitment and selling process off the streets but also allow traffickers to control victims using remote surveillance…
Here the magical “pimp” mind-control powers are claimed to be exerted via some mumbo-jumbo fantasy technology.
Lucy Steigerwald presents a pro-decriminalization argument to a conservative audience:
Unfortunately, while the war on one vice dials back, law enforcement and government fight hard against another supposed danger…these days it sure seems as if the hot new thing to swoon over and vow to “do something” about is prostitution. Worse than that, it’s prostitution-slash-sex trafficking, vaguely hand-waved together as the same thing…the solution to the latter is to legalize the former. It’s that easy. Or it could be, if people would do two things: stop filing trafficking with prostitution, and stop pretending that laws against selling and purchasing sex actually prevent people from selling and purchasing sex…Both hand-wringing liberals and worried social conservatives need to realize that some sex workers—perhaps the vast majority—have no need of rescue. They need their line of work to be taken out of the black-market shadows. They need to be left alone…We tend to look back with shame and bafflement at the obviously absurd moral panics that have gripped our society, but only after the damage has been done. We are in the middle of a sex trafficking panic that not only exaggerates the threat that prostitutes pose to the moral fiber of society but, worse still, makes enormous exaggerations about the number of sex-trafficked (mostly) women and children…
It’s like they’re not even trying any more:
Law enforcement officials on all levels – from local to international – are working together to crack down on human trafficking, which is a growing problem…[fetishists] call it “modern day slavery,” and it’s happening right here in East Tennessee…pimps…target young girls…on…social media…Interstate 40 is a convenient corridor for sex traffickers…the Community Coalition Against Human Trafficking…[trains] people to recognize victimization…traffickers and pimps employ manipulation…21 of Tennessee’s 95 counties reported at least 16 cases of sex trafficking involving a minor in 2010…
Yes, that’s the same discredited study they’re still quoting despite the fact that it isn’t even supported by the cops’ own records.
Here’s a excellent article on the State’s two-faced attitude toward “revenge porn”:
…Sex workers themselves are erased from anti–revenge-porn rhetoric. Proposed remedies for revenge porn—criminalization of disclosures and liability for third-party websites—fail to address the sex-work stigma that creates repercussions for victims of revenge porn. When a woman has her Google results bombed with nude photos and fake sex ads, she won’t pass a screening when she tries to get a job—because she’ll be mistaken for a sex worker. The solution, we conclude, is to remove all possibility of that mistake—rather than to remove what bars a sex worker from getting that job…We propose new criminal statutes and partner with the police, even as the police threaten to post photos of sex workers during “busts” on social media accounts. These are women who are being locked out of jobs because of nude photos of them on the Internet. These are women who are being publicly disgraced as sex workers—because they are sex workers…the existence of sex work raises awkward questions about how to define revenge porn, how to understand its harms, and how to most appropriately redress its victims…
And the gravy train just keeps rolling along:
Victims of human trafficking in Tampa Bay will have more access to legal help thanks to a $600,000 U.S. Department of Justice grant…Some…brothels take the form of what are called massage parlors. Gulfcoast Legal Services attorney Sophia Lynn Denicolo says they can be hotbeds of human trafficking…
Another sex work-positive article in Cosmopolitan. Hey prohibitionists: We’re winning. And there’s not a damned thing you can do about it.
There are a few rules for dating a sex worker: don’t compromise their cash flow by driving away their business, never out them to other people without their consent, and don’t expect them to eagerly perform activities they normally get paid to do for free…Ask any sex worker how they maintain their boundaries, and you’re in for a long conversation. Some people develop a working identity that they keep entirely separate from their real-life persona, and others conflate the two. Many sex workers desperately want to be out but don’t want to endure the invasive questions, or fear that their housing stability or the custody of their children would be compromised…The hardest boundary I’ve had to confront in my romantic relationships is the line between authentic desire in my work, and the “it’s just work” defense…But the world isn’t black-and-white, and while the vast majority of us are not regularly turned on by our work, real connections can happen with scene partners and genuine fun can be had with clients. So where’s the line?…
A federal appeals court has ordered the Cook County Sheriff’s Department to cease lobbying major credit card companies that do business with…Backpage.com…At a hearing on Friday, Judge Richard Posner expressed unease with the notion, presented by the sheriff department attorneys, that Dart’s First Amendment rights protected his individual right to express his displeasure with Backpage to the credit card companies…on the sheriff department’s letterhead…“He can use the office of the sheriff to express any antipathy that he has to anything?” Posner posed to the sheriff’ department attorneys. “So you’re saying there is no limit? He can express his opinion on his office stationery on any subject that occurs to him. What if he doesn’t like pets? He doesn’t think people should have animals in their house. He can suggest to everyone they euthanize their pets?” Dart was also directed by the appeals court to send a copy of the order to Visa and Mastercard and all other recipients of the June 29 letter within 24 hours…
The recording is well worth your time, especially the segment from roughly the 18 minute mark to the 30 minute mark. Dart’s mouthpiece clearly knows she’s spouting drivel, and the judges keep calling her on it.
That Judge is one smart cookie! He knows if he doesn’t shutdown this ahole sheriff now he will be forcing his morality on all of us.
I’ve listened to that recording about three times already. It might just be my new favorite song.
RE being a sex worker’s lover: One of my dearest friends and lovers was, among many other things, a brilliant sex worker. We were close friends for about 20 years until she died unexpectedly. Perhaps the second or third time we were together I asked her why she was interested in sex with me, since she was sexual on the average of once a day anyhow. She said the difference was that when she was with a client, she did what they wanted. When she was with me, I did what she wanted. And that was definitely alright with me!
Maggie,
Brothels in the middle ages were actually run by the church!
So if the Catholic church were to actually adopt [or “return to”] medieval values, it would actually constitute an improvement. 😉
Click on the link in the subtitle of that article.
When I first clicked it, I took a quick look and then went to the home page. I found a whole load of cr*p there, so I didn’t take the initial item seriously, and believed it was meant as a joke, like you would read in The Onion.
Thus my comment.
I clicked a second time on the link, and took a longer look. Still ridden with cr*p, but now I notice that this particular article cited The Independent” as a source.
The Catholic Church is known for embezzlement, shady financial deals, links to the mafia and dictatorships, child abuse… Running a brothel for those suffering sexually repressed priests isn’t even a misdemeanor, in both absolute and relative terms.
I just checked my local library to find a good reference which I could quote for the middle-age history. Depressingly, the first five-six pages of search results was practically all prohibitionist/human trafficking/victim/white slavery stuff, if I can judge by the titles. You have to go back further in time to find more serious material. There’s a good French book I remember seeing a long time ago, but it’s lent out and overdue.
Have a good week-end!
The church was alway very tolerant of sin, so long as people respected it’s authority. The rules were more about preserving a social order and they didn’t care much what people did in private.
The rule against marriage was to make sure priests would not be under the influence of their wives. They knew that if a priest was married, the local congregation would most likely be ruled by the wife and not the church. When you prevent your priests from getting married, you know they’re going to need mistresses and prostitutes even more than the usual man.
I think the prohibition on marriage dealt with inheritance. Church property was not to be passed on to heirs, but remain in the church.
Up until the 10th century, priests married women landowners to bring thier property into the Church.
This can be another reason. But I thought priest had a vow of poverty, meaning they didn’t officially own anything of value in their own name. A local catholic priest would live in a presbytery next to the church which was usually owned by the community or the church. This has been in practice for so long that the original justifications probably also evolved along with society.
Not all Catholic priests take a vow of poverty.
Diocesan priests do not.
https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Diocesan_priest
Religious order priests often required to take a vow of poverty and not own items individually.
Not only the diocesan… German bishop Franz-Peter Tebartz-van Elst certainly did not…
@Francois. Exactly, apart from a very small number who are genuinely asexual, priests have the same sexual needs as any other man. This is something that the church used to understand, at least to some degree.
No, I mean the link in the subtitle “The Lesser of Two Evils”. I have no control over what other people link on other sites.
OK. Let’s chalk it up to cultural differences.
Apropos medieval Catholicism…
Have you ever heard or seen Imperia, a monument on the port of Constance in southwest Germany?
It is a 30 feet high statue of a self-assured courtesan who holds in the palm of her hands the pope and the emperor of Germany, naked, powerless, and generally looking ridiculous.
It evokes the four-year long Council of Constance that took place there beginning 1414. The size of the city ballooned, and quite a business developed to cater to the more intimate needs of those men officially busy with more supernatural issues…
The rotating statue was erected in 1993 amid a storm of controversy, which left a trace in Wikipedia. The German language entry does a fair job telling the story, but in all other languages [including Latin, I wonder who put up that one…] the key historical elements were left out, but the inaccuracy of the novel by Balzac from which the statue’s name is drawn was emphasized.
“Let’s make a clear distinction for once and all, many attackers of sex workers are not or will never be “sex buyers”.”
Alice (of Alice’s Bookshop) once told me a story, that someone exclaimed to her “It’s just so dreadful that your customers steal the books!”. She replied, “Customers don’t steal my books. *Thieves* steal my books.”
Re: Judge Posner decision – so many religious types that are sactimonous about government non-interference don’t seem to get it that *they* are the government when acting in a government job.