In its moral simplicity and willingness to exploit its subjects, [Hot Girls Wanted] ends up resembling the genre it aims to expose. – Susan Shepard
…Hot Girls Wanted…looks at five young women who were recruited off of Craigslist by an “agent” in Miami, Florida named Riley from Hussie Models. It was directed by Jill Bauer and Ronna Gradus, whose previous documentary Sexy Baby, looked at an alleged cultural shift in the sexual landscape that, the women claim, was caused by adult entertainment…Writing in Vice, Susan Elizabeth Shepard notes that the team’s new film is actually an exercise in offering “unexamined statements and vague intimations about how doing porn harms women and watching it warps men”…one of the documentary’s subjects, ex-performer Ava Taylor …oozed a sense of entitlement…she wanted to make money and get famous fast…the dressed down and bespectacled Ava…claims to be out of sex work…[she] is angry and combative, hurling blame at producers, her agent, and even the testing system for adult performers. On one of her Twitter accounts, she has repeated how glad she is to be out, and moving on with her life…However…two months after Hot Girls Wanted premiered, Ava was back in Los Angeles shooting brand new porn scenes…[she also] currently offers escort services online…
The national “safe harbor” law is just as useless and dishonest as the state ones:
The average sex-trafficking victim is a 13-year-old girl, often forced into the illicit business against her will and fed illegal drugs to keep her tethered to her pimp. These children need housing, education, jobs and hope for a future — not a criminal rap sheet, says U.S. Sen. Amy Klobuchar…President Obama signed a law championed by Klobuchar that…creates financial incentives for states to pass laws that ensure minors sold for sex aren’t prosecuted, but are instead treated as victims…
…The latest hit to companies who are actively anti-sex industry is a lawsuit against the payment processor Square. Xbiz reports that attorney William McGrane is taking them to court with the claim that the 27 business categories in…“Prohibited Businesses” are being discriminated against and having their civil rights violated under the policy. According to McGrane, the majority of the types…listed are either too vague to be valid or are legal businesses, making it illegal for Square to discriminate against them…
When the cops raided Ginnifer Hency’s home in Smiths Creek, Michigan…”they took everything,” she told state legislators…including TV sets, ladders, her children’s cellphones and iPads, even her vibrator. They found six ounces of marijuana and arrested Hency for possession with intent to deliver, “even though I was fully compliant with the Michigan medical marijuana laws”…Hency, a mother of four with multiple sclerosis, uses marijuana for pain relief based on her neurologist’s recommendation. She also serves as a state-registered caregiver for five other patients…[the] judge dismissed the charges against her. But when she asked about getting back her property… “The prosecutor came out to me and said, ‘Well, I can still beat you in civil court. I can still take your stuff’…the Michigan House Judiciary Committee [is] considering several bills that would make this sort of legalized larceny more difficult…Annette Shattuck, another medical marijuana patient…was [robbed of]…bicycles, her husband’s tools, a lawn mower, a weed whacker, her children’s Christmas presents, cash (totaling $85) taken from her daughter’s birthday cards, the kids’ car seats and soccer equipment, and vital documents such as driver’s licenses, insurance cards, and birth certificates…
Another jurisdiction officially classifies women as passive objects without agency:
[Chicago] officials have launched a new alternative program for men and women charged with prostitution…the new court would help connect the women – and sometimes men – connect with social services so they can turn away from prostitution…“and turn their lives around”…Cook County Public Defender Amy Campanelli said, instead of prosecution, defendants will get mostly treatment and help from social service agencies. “They will learn how to break their pasts, and cut all ties with those who have abused them, or dragged them into living lives of desperation”…
The US government knew about the now-infamous deceptions and malpractice within organisations run by Somaly Mam for years prior to the media exposés…last year. Even so, Washington continued to see her as a “positive force in the anti-trafficking effort”, despite evidence that medical care at her shelters was not available and that her…NGO, Afesip, had “mismanaged” funds…A cable titled Somaly Mam Under Microscope sent to the State Department from the embassy in Phnom Penh on May 8, 2012, shows that the embassy suspected as early as 2006 that a key claim repeated by Mam over the years – that her daughter was abducted in 2006 in revenge for an Afesip raid on a Phnom Penh brothel in 2004 – was false…
News media used to just report news; now they allow propagandists to make bogus predictions of disaster:
From 1 June, it will be illegal to pay for sex in Northern Ireland…The Immigrant Council of Ireland and…Turn Off The Red Light…will…call for similar laws to come into force in the south immediately…[because] counties south of the border will become “more attractive for pimps, traffickers and thugs”…
And then gin up fake “statistics” to support their own predictions:
Pimps and prostitutes are moving into the border counties as a crackdown on the sex trade in Northern Ireland comes into force, campaigners have warned. There has been more than a 50 per cent rise in online sex trade activity in counties Donegal, Cavan, Monaghan, Leitrim and Louth in recent weeks, according to a study by the Immigrant Council of Ireland…Brian Killoran…of the ICI…said the Border counties now face being used as a “safe haven” for sex traders in the absence of a similar ban by the Dublin government. “The initial indications are that those who run prostitution have been feeling the heat of Northern Ireland’s new laws even before they came into force and have been switching their operations to the south”…
Yes, they’re actually claiming the laws had effects reaching into the future.
More than a year after the starting fight for legal personhood for the research chimpanzees Hercules and Leo, the apes and their lawyers got their day in court…A decision could set a precedent for challenging…the captivity of other chimpanzees—and perhaps other species…New York assistant attorney general Christopher Coulston…argued that [the judge] was bound by the previous decisions of two appellate courts, which had ruled that other Nonhuman Rights Project chimps didn’t qualify for habeas corpus…Both those decisions are controversial. In one, judges decided that habeas corpus didn’t apply because the chimp would be transferred from one form of captivity to another—in this case, a sanctuary. But illegally-held human prisoners have been released to mental hospitals, and juveniles into the care of guardians. In the other appeals court decision, judges declared that chimps are not legal persons because they can’t fulfill duties to human society. But that rationale arguably denies personhood to young children and mentally incapacitated individuals, as several high-profile legal scholars…pointed out…
Because “trafficking” means anything we want it to mean!
Ed Smart…visited east Idaho…to attend a screening of a documentary about child sex trafficking…“When Elizabeth was abducted do we think of her being enslaved?…She absolutely was…she was assaulted once twice a day for almost every day of the nine months she was gone.” Smart is now on a mission to rescue children from sex trafficking. He’s working with Operation Underground Railroad….“Any time you have a resort area more than likely trafficking is going on there. Any time there’s a big sporting event in the United States you can believe trafficking is going on.” Operation Underground Railroad has produced a new documentary called The Abolitionists. It shows investigators rescuing endangered children and going after the adult perpetrators around the world…
It’s hard to tell the worst part of this “end demand” propaganda. Is it the bullshit claim that women aren’t being arrested because they’re forced into “re-education” rather than jail? The badge-licking description of cops hunting down people seeking to engage in consensual sex? The Orwellian euphemism “recovering a victim” used to mean “arresting a woman”? The cop bragging about how many women he’s arrested? The pervasive denial of female agency? The description of a prosecutor as a “defense attorney”? Or the fact that neither warped billionaire Swanee Hunt (the architect of the fascist program Seattle is participating in) nor her “CEASE Network” front organization are mentioned at all, even though she paid for the policy change with grants?
The average age of entry into prostitution in the United States is 14. The kind of profit a pimp can expect to make on a child prostitute each year is $150,000. Child trafficking operations spend about $45 million a year advertising their services on literally thousands of sites and millions of pages…Two computer science professors, Pedro Szekely and Craig Knoblock…have developed a new search tool intended to…turn advertising against human traffickers. The work is being funded by Memex, a Defense Advanced Research Projects Agency (DARPA) program aimed at developing the next generation of search technologies…The tool they’ve created combs through escort ads; downloads all relevant pages, including the ones those ads link to; discovers connections, folds the data into a repository; and provides query and analysis functionality to enable searching by law enforcement users…Currently, the database contains content from 50 million Web pages and 2 billion records; it’s growing at the rate of about 5,000 Web pages per hour…
Why are amateurs so surprised that sex workers use ordinary business tools?
…in Zimbabwe…many people in the informal economy make use of [a South African cell phone payment service named] EcoCash and sex workers are no exception, with some carrying multiple phones. “If I’ve got 20, 30 or 50 bucks and I’m not going to use it, I will put it in EcoCash,” says Ncube. “Even if someone steals my bag, I will open my mobile wallet tomorrow and the money will still be there”…Officials…express surprise at the swift integration of mobile money. Jessie Majome, a former deputy minister of women’s affairs, says…“Wow. Hi-tech sex work. I’m struck how early they’ve adapted to that”…
There were very similar stories in many news media about the “hordes” of sex workers and their pimps crossing the border from N Ireland into the Republic of Ireland. These “stories” seem to originate from TORL (Turn off the Red Light), an “anti” consortium, and were lifted almost word for word from a press release.
Laura Lee—who else?—thoroughly debunked this:
http://feministire.com/2015/06/03/lies-damn-lies-and-torl-statistics/
ICI is the Immigrant Council of Ireland.
Well, it’s like this Maggie.
When we imagine ‘sex worker tools of the trade’ we sort of get distracted down all these little byways and never get around to thinking about how the accounting might work.
Or is that just me?
If you do run across someone kinky for a well turned balance sheet they’re probably gonna work for the tax department or something.
Whores are all dumb bitches… er, I mean “uneducated victims”… and therefore it’s quite shocking that they’ve even heard of the internet, let alone know how to keep up with the latest technology and apps.
It must be the evil, cunning pimps that are training them how to use these services.
I’m sure the migrating hordes of Irish prostitutes are exagerated, but still people react to a law usually before they are implemented. For instance, in Canada, the forums moved to foreign servers well before the new law came into effect, and clients started being more careful and worried.
yes the forums moved, but beyond that there are many, many people involved in the sex trade as both buyers and sellers who have absolutely no idea C-36 exists or what it is intended to do so I rather doubt that there has been much movement across the Irish border. Most people are woefully uninformed about the world around them. Useful idiots and low information votes make social engineers giddy
My point was just that whatever real effect a law has, it will happen even before it is effective. The scale of mass migrations is spurious, but not the claim that it would ”happen” before the law.
However, in a small place like Ireland, supposing a short drive gets you to a place with a better law, wouldn’t you expect many clients/workers to just go there to buy and sell? Escorts and clients cross borders all the time in Europe.
“Most people are woefully uninformed about the world around them. Useful idiots and low information votes make social engineers giddy”
Yet somehow people being told to their face, in essence, “you’re an idiot, let me explain to you why you’re an idiot so I can live my life without your idiocy” usually doesn’t make people want to listen to you and consider their ideas.
So what’s to be done then? If people are such idiots and so easily swayed, what’s keeping people like you from swaying them the other way? Libertarians and anarcho-capitalists seem to know all of the rhetorical and statistical tricks the enemies of freedom use, and they know what their remedies are. Yet they haven’t figured out how to actually get to the point where they can implement their remedies. Why? Is it a morality thing? What’s moral about allowing so-called ‘idiots’ to cause you pain and suffering through their idiocy?
I must not understand something. I guess that makes me an idiot.
The term ”useful idiot” does not refer to the population at large, but rather to the groups of fanatic ideologues. You won’t change the opinions of those people. They are idiots because the government uses them to achieve their own goals that have nothing to do with what these groups are supposedly fighting for. (For exemple feminists who support laws that infantilize women).
The general public is just not well informed and mostly doesn’t care about issues like sex work. Most people can be convinced if presented with evidence, but it takes a lot of time and effort to get yourself well informed on a subject. They see that the most vocal feminists support a type of law, so they just think it’s good for women.
Fair enough, you may not use “useful idiot” to describe the population at large, but I find it difficult to escape the impression among libertarians and anarcho-capitalists of a barely concealed contempt for a large portion of humanity, beyond just the politicians and their ‘idiots’. How many times have we read complaints about people voting against their own best interests, read of people giving up on society because they have not yet seen the light?
I’m probably oversimplifying but if I had to boil it down, the left considers the right evil, the right considers the left evil, they both consider the libertarians evil and the libertarians consider everyone evil except themselves.
It’s as if we’re resigning ourselves to the conclusion that since everyone else are irredeemable, barely sentient morons, and it’s immoral to force them to be otherwise (thus alleviating everyone’s problems), we have to consign ourselves to being miserable alongside them, complaining about how idiotic people are while we wait for some miraculous “burning down of the system” that just might allow those who survive to start anew.
the problem as I see it is not so much the view of pure evil on the other end of the spectrum but the inability to see when the other side actually has a good idea. Not that there is really much difference between the major parties of the U.S.. they aren’t really different in matters witch may affect society. The differences are a matter of degrees. large gov’t party slightly to the side of the other doesn’t make any difference at the end of the day.
Few people are irredeemable morons but they are the ones who get most of the mainstream media and too many people are sheep who are too afraid to go against the grain. I admit to occasionally silencing myself with some of my opinions since liberal debate simply became calling anyone who doesn’t agree with you names. Usually bigot or racist or misogynist or homophobe
This is very timely, Maggie, and I appreciate the research: I had just seen the documentary myself yesterday, and was resigned to the fact that, yes, there are some who are severely disappointed in their foray into the industry, and they all make the move willingly. That can be true of any job.
I am sure the doc will be cited tomorrow at the data collection meeting of the county trafficking task force, but the doc has nothing to do with trafficking. I’ll let you all know how that one turns out.
In the doc Ava Taylor bemoaned the fact that she was just a piece of meat, and that that was all anyone saw her to be. I wonder if she did any research prior to arriving in Miami? Another comment from one of the young women was that sex didn’t mean anything anymore. It is clear the film-makers wanted to show only their point.
Possibly the most annoying thing about Hot Girls Wanted was how close it came to having scraps of insight. Sex work is difficult, taxing, sometimes unpleasant, sometimes uncomfortable, often unsexy work; people choose to do it for all kinds of reasons and people choose to stop doing it for all kinds of reasons – these things came across (at least to me) very strongly. But instead of looking at all that and considering how the industry can be made less difficult, less uncomfortable, less taxing, the filmmakers just pointed at it and said “See? Evil.”