Fundamental[ly]…policing [is]…a state institution that’s predicated on the use of violence to fix problems. – Alex Vitale
What Were You All Waiting For?
Is the ACLU finally beginning to do the right thing, at long last?
Sex workers aren’t always a part of [amateurs’] conversation about police brutality, but they should be. Police regularly target, harass, and assault sex workers or people they think are sex workers…[and] usually get away with the abuse because sex workers fear being arrested if they report. If we lived in a world that didn’t criminalize sex work, sex workers could better protect themselves and seek justice when they are harmed. Protecting sex workers from police violence is just one of the reasons we need to decriminalize sex work…
A murderer is also a rapist. Gee, what a surprise:
…one of three white officers accused in the death of Breonna Taylor…[also molested at least] two women [in the past. Brett Hankinson]…is…a dirty cop [who has also carried out] vendetta[s by] arrest[ing people he dislikes on trumped-up charges]…the more recent sexual assault…[was] against…a woman [named]…Margo Borders w[ho reported that Hankinson] …”drove me home [from a bar] in uniform, in his marked car, invited himself into my apartment and sexually assaulted me while I was unconscious”…In the second instance…Emily Terry…”began walking home from a bar intoxicated. A [cop] pulled up next to me and offered me a ride home…He began making sexual advances towards me…As soon as he pulled up to my apartment building, I got out of the car and ran to the back”…
Amazon wants to have its cake and eat it too:
We’re implementing a one-year moratorium on police use of Amazon’s facial recognition technology. We will continue to allow organizations like Thorn, the International Center for Missing and Exploited Children, and Marinus Analytics to use Amazon Rekognition to [persecute sex workers] and [pass the information on to the cops]…
In other words, Amazon is adopting a cosmetic ban in order to take advantage of the anti-cop zeitgeist while simultaneously profiting from helping notorious fascist anti-sex organizations to persecute sex workers and pass the information along to their pig buddies.
Another sign that the moral panic may be dying:
For the second year in a row, the number of federal human trafficking cases…has dropped after almost two decades of increases…Overall, federal p[er]secutions of [people using the excuse of] human traffick[ing] have dropped by about a third since 2017…The decrease came entirely from a drop in prosecutions of sex trafficking…which has consistently made up the majority of federal human trafficking prosecutions since the TVPA was enacted. The number of labor trafficking cases has remained roughly the same, [because unike “sex trafficking” they are based in reality]…The number of new sex trafficking cases, meanwhile, dropped from 207 in 2017 to just 136 filed in 2019…
…thousands of small children who are led out of schools in handcuffs every year around the country. Juvenile arrests in Florida have been steadily declining over the last decade, as they have been more generally across the U.S., but…the state embarked on an aggressive plan to “harden” its…[treatment of students], including putting at least one [armed, dangerous thug] in every K-12 school in the state…[the result is that] students, especially minorities and those with disabilities, are now bearing the brunt of new zero tolerance policies and heavy-handed discipline…In Minneapolis…the school board recently voted in favor of…ending a $1 million [cash cow for]…city police. Mayor Ted Wheeler of Portland, Oregon, announced…that he would disband the city’s school [pig herd]…Other states and cities appear to be considering similar measures. [But] in Florida [police violence against students] increased…20%…[and] there’s been a spike in the use of involuntary psychiatric commitments against kids…thanks to an existing Florida…that gives police authority to temporarily lock up both children and adults against their will…
Alex Vitale on what abolishing police would actually look like:
Five years ago, in the wake of the murders of Mike Brown and Eric Garner and Tamir Rice, we were told, “Don’t worry, we’re going to fix it. We’re going to give the police implicit bias training. We’re going to hold some community police encounter sessions. We’re gonna buy some body cameras”…what we often refer to as “procedural reforms”…[were] going to magically fix the problem. But…the problem of overpolicing remains…Procedural justice folks…want to restore the public’s trust in the police…But this ignores the question of what they are policing, and whether they should be policing it. We have [millions of] low-level arrests in the United States every year and most of them are completely pointless. It is just a huge level of harassment meted out almost exclusively on the poorest and most marginal communities in our society…[true police reform must] go…hand in hand with decriminalizing sex work, drugs, homelessness, mental illness. We don’t really need a vice unit, we need a system of legalized sex work that’s regulated just like any other business. We don’t need school police, we need counselors and restorative justice programs. We don’t need police homeless outreach units, we need supportive housing, community based drop-in centers, social workers…
Just a reminder that there was a time — when Margo St James was leading COYOTE and Teri Goodson was in SF NOW — that the ACLU supported decriminalization as fundamental to women’s equality. What I find fascinating is new emphasis tying sex workers’ rights to transgender equality, and intersectionally, to Black Lives Matter. That the riot at Compton’s Cafeteria in San Francisco (which predates Stonewall) was led by trans sex workers of color against police harassment and brutality is a reminder that the struggle has always been against state and patriarchal violence.
Thank you for that reminder. I followed the events in those pre-internet days as much as possible given the limitations of the local area’s media.
Margo St. James was then and is now a little sung early whoreo (a portmanteau of whore and hero.
At the time, she founded two short-lived organizations: WHO (Whores, Housewives and Others), which morphed into COYOTE (Call Off Your Tired Old Ethics).
I was young then, and had hope that a more widespread movement could develop within NOW (National Organization of Women) . Little did I know that a pernicious whore-hatred movement would infect and spread within NOW as it grew.
Her activism was both intelligent and tireless. It ran the gamut from founding the annual SF Hooker’s Ball, to a lawsuit in Rhode Island leading to the General Assembly decriminalizing prostitution in 1980, through internationally organizing decriminalization activism in France, and founding the San Francisco St. James Infirmary Clinic, to provide health care to sex workers.
Her last known residence is on Orcas Island, not far as the crow flies from that of our gracious host,
Some details of Margo St. James’ accomplishments are readily available in Wikipedia.
Pyrrhic Victory:
Sounds to me like this will not even slow-down anything at all. Basically it sounds like they looked into their project plans how long they could pretend to stop things without really disrupting anything.
…use of violence to fix problems:
Classical cave-man thinking. Has never worked, will never work. Violence just begets violence. Quite obviously. When all you can do is escalate, all you get is escalation. And that really benefits nobody long-term.